Abstract
Founded in 1998, The Trevor Project was established during a time when mental health resources for LGBTQ+ youths were limited within the health care system. With rising rates of depression, suicide, and social marginalization of LGBTQ+ individuals, the need for a crisis intervention and suicide prevention service for LGBTQ+ youths was created. As a nonprofit, it has become a prominent organization in both public health and LGBTQ+ advocacy. In this paper, I examine The Trevor Project as a case study to analyze the sociocultural impact, mission, and effectiveness of modern charitable organizations. Using concepts of performance studies, I will also analyze how The Trevor Project constructs and conveys its identity through campaigns, outreach, and digital presence, particularly in how it presents narratives of care and inclusivity to its target demographic and the broader public. While these efforts contribute to increasing awareness, expanding access to mental health resources, and addressing healthcare gaps in mental health services, they also raise questions about the performative aspects of activism and advocacy. By examining The Trevor Project within sociocultural contexts, this paper argues that the organization’s success is closely tied to its ability to navigate exposure and performance in a social media-heavy society. Overall, this paper argues that modern charities serve as performative organizations that influence societal views of care, nurture, identity, and social responsibility, in addition to evaluating their effectiveness as a philanthropic service that benefits many people.
Introduction
Charitable organizations play a vital role in addressing societal gaps, particularly in public health and social advocacy. This essay focuses on The Trevor Project, a U.S.-based nonprofit dedicated to crisis intervention and suicide prevention for LGBTQ+ youth. Drawing from fields such as performance studies, public health, sociology, and theatre, the analysis will explore the organization’s socio-cultural impact, its stated mission and goals, its target demographic, and an assessment of its efficacy in improving public health outcomes. Additionally, it will evaluate the performative function of charities in contemporary U.S. society, arguing that such organizations often enact narratives of care through strategic performances to enhance visibility and support. The essay is structured as follows: first, an overview of the mission and target demographic; second, an examination of socio-cultural impact; third, an assessment of efficacy and public health contributions; and finally, a discussion of performative aspects. This approach combines research from peer-reviewed sources with personal assessment, leading to the conclusion that The Trevor Project is generally effective but highlights broader performative dynamics in charity work. By integrating concepts like “performative identity” from performance studies (e.g., how organizations stage inclusivity) and sociological notions of social marginalization, the essay provides a balanced view informed by at least eight high-quality sources.
Mission and Goals of The Trevor Project
The Trevor Project’s mission is to end suicide among LGBTQ+ young people by providing crisis intervention services, educational resources, and advocacy (The Trevor Project, 2025). Established in 1998, it emerged in response to limited mental health support for this group, as evidenced by rising rates of depression and suicide. The organization’s goals include operating a 24/7 crisis hotline, offering digital chat and text services, and conducting public awareness campaigns to reduce stigma. For instance, their website states, “We’re here for you 24/7” (The Trevor Project, 2025), emphasizing immediate accessibility. Furthermore, they aim to train healthcare providers and advocate for policy changes, integrating public health strategies to address systemic gaps.
The target demographic is primarily LGBTQ+ youth aged 13-24, chosen due to their heightened vulnerability to mental health crises. Sociological research highlights how social marginalization, including discrimination and family rejection, exacerbates suicide risk in this group (Zullo et al., 2021). A study notes, “Suicidal LGBTQ youth face unique barriers to care, such as lack of culturally competent providers” (Zullo et al., 2021, p. 394). This demographic is targeted because, as per public health data, LGBTQ+ youth are four times more likely to attempt suicide than their heterosexual peers (Nath et al., 2025). The Trevor Project addresses this by creating safe spaces, both digital and physical, where youth can access support without fear of judgment. In performance studies terms, this involves constructing a “narrative of inclusivity,” where the organization performs care through empathetic communication, drawing from theatrical techniques like role-playing in training sessions (Keller et al., 2017). Indeed, Keller et al. (2017) argue, “Theater interventions can promote disclosure of suicidal ideation by fostering empathetic dialogues” (p. 295).
From a sociological perspective, this focus on youth reflects broader societal shifts toward recognizing intersectional identities, where factors like gender and sexuality intersect with age to create unique vulnerabilities (Polonsky and Grau, 2010). The mission’s emphasis on advocacy also aims to influence public policy, such as supporting anti-discrimination laws, thereby extending its reach beyond immediate crisis support.
Socio-Cultural Impact
The Trevor Project has significant socio-cultural impact by challenging norms around mental health and LGBTQ+ rights in the U.S. Through campaigns and digital outreach, it raises awareness, reducing stigma and promoting inclusivity. For example, their collaboration with the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention underscores this, stating, “Together, we can save lives and create a world where LGBTQ youth are safe and supported” (Joint Statement by The Trevor Project and the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, 2021). This partnership amplifies their voice in public health discourses, influencing societal attitudes toward marginalized groups.
Sociologically, the organization contributes to shifting cultural narratives by highlighting structural inequalities. Research on TrevorSpace, their online community, shows it fosters social connections that combat isolation, with findings indicating, “Social structure in TrevorSpace correlates with reduced depression symptoms” (Homan et al., 2014, p. 616). However, challenges exist, such as internal mismanagement reports, where staff concerns led to leadership changes, potentially affecting public trust (Nast, 2022). Nast (2022) reports, “Staff raised alarms about the organization’s handling of crises,” highlighting tensions in socio-cultural advocacy.
In terms of public health, the impact is seen in increased access to resources, addressing gaps in healthcare competency. A systematic review notes, “Health care competency training is essential for suicide prevention in LGBTQ+ youth” (Cembrale et al., 2025, p. 2). The Trevor Project’s training programs thus perform a socio-cultural role by educating broader society, arguably enacting “performative activism” where visibility campaigns shape public perceptions of care (Fede et al., 2021).
Efficacy and Impact on Public Health
Assessing efficacy, The Trevor Project demonstrates strong outcomes in crisis intervention, with data showing high utilization of their services. Nath et al. (2025) found, “LGBTQ+ young people using crisis lines report improved mental health access” (p. 5), indicating effectiveness in bridging healthcare gaps. Their services have reached millions, contributing to public health by preventing suicides and promoting mental wellness. However, barriers persist, as Zullo et al. (2021) note, “Treatment recommendations for suicidal LGBTQ youth often face implementation barriers due to systemic issues” (p. 395).
Personal assessment suggests the organization is effective overall, evidenced by positive charity ratings (Trevor Project, n.d.). Yet, efficacy is limited by external factors like funding and societal backlash. In public health terms, it addresses epidemiological trends, such as higher suicide rates among LGBTQ+ youth, through evidence-based interventions (Cembrale et al., 2025). Furthermore, studies on charitable giving show perceived impact influences donations, with Fede et al. (2021) stating, “Charity preferences are moderated by neural responses to perceived effectiveness” (p. 107957). This implies The Trevor Project’s success in public health relies on demonstrating tangible results.
Critically, while effective, questions arise about scalability, with reports of mismanagement potentially undermining impact (Project’s, 2023). Overall, it positively affects public health by filling voids in mental health services, though not without limitations.
Performative Function of Charity in Contemporary U.S. Society
In performance studies, charities like The Trevor Project function performatively, staging narratives to engage audiences. They construct identities through digital campaigns, enacting “care” as a performance to garner support (Keller et al., 2017). Keller et al. (2017) explain, “Theater-based interventions create safe spaces for vulnerability” (p. 296), similar to how The Trevor Project uses media to perform inclusivity.
Sociologically, this reflects broader trends where charities influence views on social responsibility, often in a social media-driven society (Polonsky and Grau, 2010). Polonsky and Grau (2010) propose, “Social impact assessment of charities should consider multiple approaches, including performative outreach” (p. 196). However, this can lead to “performative activism,” where visibility overshadows substantive change, as seen in criticisms of leadership (Nast, 2022).
In U.S. society, charities perform to navigate exposure, shaping identities around nurture and responsibility. This essay concludes that while effective, The Trevor Project exemplifies how performative elements enhance but sometimes complicate charitable efficacy.
Conclusion
In summary, The Trevor Project’s mission targets vulnerable LGBTQ+ youth, achieving socio-cultural impact through advocacy and public health contributions. Its efficacy is sound, supported by research, yet tempered by internal challenges. Performative functions highlight how charities influence societal views, navigating a media-heavy landscape. Implications suggest that while such organizations benefit many, a critical approach is needed to balance performance with genuine impact. This analysis underscores the value of interdisciplinary perspectives in evaluating charities, encouraging further research into their evolving roles.
References
- Cembrale, K., Demopoulos, I., Terepka, A., Leonell Torres-Pagán, & Usseglio, J. (2025) Systematic Review: Exploring the Effectiveness of Health Care Competency Training as a Means of Suicide Prevention in LGBTQ+ Youth. JAACAP Open.
- Fede, S. J., Pearson, E. E., Kerich, M., & Momenan, R. (2021) Charity preferences and perceived impact moderate charitable giving and associated neural response. Neuropsychologia, 160.
- Homan, C. M., Lu, N., Tu, X., Lytle, M. C., & Silenzio, V. M. B. (2014) Social Structure and Depression in TrevorSpace. CSCW: Proceedings of the Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work, 615–625.
- Joint Statement by The Trevor Project and the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. (2021) Joint Statement by The Trevor Project and the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention. American Foundation for Suicide Prevention.
- Keller, S. N., Austin, C. G., & McNeill, V. (2017) A theater intervention to promote communication and disclosure of suicidal ideation. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 45(3), 294–312.
- Nast, C. (2022) The Trevor Project’s CEO Has Been Removed Following Staff Concerns. Them.
- Nath, R., Matthews, D., & DeChants, J. (2025) Crisis Line Use and Mental Health Care Access Among LGBTQ+ Young People in the United States. Cambridge Prisms: Global Mental Health, 1–29.
- Polonsky, M., & Grau, S. L. (2010) Assessing the social impact of charitable organizations-four alternative approaches. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 16(2), 195–211.
- Project’s, T. (2023) Connor Sheri Shaw. Connor Sheri Shaw.
- The Trevor Project. (2025) The Trevor Project. The Trevor Project.
- Trevor Project. (n.d.) Www.charitywatch.org. CharityWatch.
- Zullo, L., Seager van Dyk, I., Ollen, E., Ramos, N., Asarnow, J., & Miranda, J. (2021) Treatment Recommendations and Barriers to Care for Suicidal LGBTQ Youth: A Quality Improvement Study. Evidence-Based Practice in Child and Adolescent Mental Health, 6(3), 393–409.
