Times New Roman, 12-point font, double-spaced
Your Name
English Literature
Course Title
Date
In the timeless realm of Greek tragedy, Sophocles’ Antigone stands as a profound exploration of human conflict and moral duty, where characters face devastating consequences for their choices. The concept of the tragic hero, as defined by the philosopher Aristotle in his seminal work Poetics, provides a lens through which to examine the intricate interplay of fate and personal responsibility. Aristotle posits that a tragic hero must possess a tragic flaw, experience a reversal of fortune, and evoke pity or fear in the audience, among other traits. This essay argues that Antigone, more than Creon, embodies the Aristotelian definition of a tragic hero through her noble birth, her tragic flaw of excessive pride, and the profound pity and fear she inspires in the audience. By analyzing these three characteristics, this paper will demonstrate how Antigone’s personal decisions and inherent flaws lead to her inevitable downfall.
Noble Birth and High Standing
Yes: Antigone, as a central figure in Sophocles’ play, undeniably fits the Aristotelian criterion of being of high standing. Evidence: She is the daughter of Oedipus, the former king of Thebes, and thus a princess by birth, which aligns with Aristotle’s assertion that tragic heroes are typically of noble lineage (Aristotle, 335 BCE). Support: Her status is not merely honorary; it carries significant weight in the societal structure of Thebes, positioning her actions under intense scrutiny and amplifying the consequences of her defiance. Furthermore, her noble birth underscores the magnitude of her fall, as the loss of a royal figure reverberates through the community, a key element in Greek tragedy. Ma’am (Conclusion): Therefore, Antigone’s elevated status establishes her as a fitting tragic hero, whose downfall impacts not just her personally, but the very fabric of Theban society.
Tragic Flaw of Excessive Pride
Yes: Central to Antigone’s tragic arc is her hamartia, or tragic flaw, manifested as excessive pride or hubris. Evidence: Her unwavering determination to bury her brother Polynices, despite Creon’s edict, reflects a stubborn adherence to divine law over human decree, declaring, “I will bury him myself” (Sophocles, 81). Support: While her commitment to family honor and divine duty is admirable, it is also her refusal to compromise or consider the political ramifications that precipitates her downfall. Indeed, this rigid pride blinds her to Creon’s authority and the potential for negotiation, driving her towards a fatal confrontation. Ma’am (Conclusion): Thus, Antigone’s hubris, though rooted in moral conviction, becomes the critical flaw that Aristotle identifies as essential to a tragic hero’s demise.
Evoking Pity and Fear in the Audience
Yes: Finally, Antigone’s journey evokes the integral Aristotelian emotions of pity and fear in the audience, fulfilling a core purpose of tragedy. Evidence: Her unyielding resolve leads to her entombment and eventual death, a fate that elicits deep sympathy as she laments her isolation, “I go to wed the lord of the dark waters” (Sophocles, 908). Support: The audience pities her for the personal cost of her principles, yet fears the universal implications of such a conflict between individual conscience and state law—a tension that remains relevant even today. Moreover, her punishment seems disproportionate, intensifying the cathartic response Aristotle describes. Ma’am (Conclusion): Consequently, Antigone’s plight fulfills the emotional objective of tragedy, cementing her status as a tragic hero through the profound impact on the audience.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Antigone exemplifies the Aristotelian tragic hero through her noble birth, her tragic flaw of excessive pride, and the profound pity and fear she evokes in the audience. Her high standing as a princess of Thebes establishes the societal significance of her fall, while her hubris in defying Creon’s decree directly leads to her tragic end. Furthermore, her suffering resonates emotionally, fulfilling the cathartic purpose of tragedy. These elements collectively affirm Antigone’s role as a tragic hero, whose personal errors and decisions—rather than mere accident or bad luck—shape her downfall. Ultimately, her story serves as a timeless reminder of the devastating consequences of irreconcilable moral and political conflicts, a theme that continues to haunt human experience.
References
- Aristotle. (335 BCE) Poetics. Translated by S.H. Butcher. Oxford University Press.
- Sophocles. (441 BCE) Antigone. Translated by Robert Fagles. Penguin Classics.
