Introduction
This essay examines the historical development of Human Resource Management (HRM) from the 1800s to the present, with a particular focus on its relevance to the field of travel and tourism. As a student of Travel and Tourism, understanding HRM is crucial because the industry heavily relies on human capital—employees who deliver exceptional customer service, manage operations, and drive business growth. The evolution of HRM reflects broader societal, economic, and technological changes, which have shaped how organisations, including those in tourism, manage their workforce. This essay will trace key milestones in HRM’s development, from early industrial practices to modern strategic approaches, highlighting their implications for the travel and tourism sector. The discussion will cover the origins of personnel management during the Industrial Revolution, the emergence of scientific management and human relations theories, the formalisation of HRM in the mid-20th century, and contemporary trends influenced by globalisation and technology. Through this analysis, the essay aims to provide a sound understanding of HRM’s progression and its application to current industry challenges.
Origins of Personnel Management in the Industrial Revolution (1800s)
The roots of HRM can be traced back to the Industrial Revolution in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, a period marked by rapid industrialisation and urbanisation, particularly in the UK. Factories emerged as central to economic production, necessitating the management of large workforces. During this time, early forms of personnel management focused on labour control rather than employee welfare. Employers, often driven by profit motives, imposed harsh working conditions, long hours, and minimal wages. However, some progressive industrialists, such as Robert Owen (1771–1858), advocated for better treatment of workers. Owen, a factory owner, introduced reforms at his New Lanark mills, including shorter working hours and improved living conditions, arguing that employee well-being directly impacted productivity (Cole, 2002). While his ideas were pioneering, they were not widely adopted at the time.
In the context of travel and tourism, this period saw the embryonic stages of the industry with the advent of organised travel through Thomas Cook’s package tours in the 1840s. Managing workers in early tourism enterprises, though rudimentary, began to mirror industrial HRM practices by focusing on task allocation rather than employee development. These early approaches laid the groundwork for more systematic personnel management, though they lacked the strategic focus of modern HRM.
Scientific Management and the Early 20th Century
The early 20th century marked a significant shift in HRM with the introduction of Frederick Taylor’s Scientific Management theory, published in 1911. Taylor emphasised efficiency through task standardisation, time-motion studies, and incentivised pay systems. His approach treated workers as resources to be optimised, often disregarding their emotional or social needs (Taylor, 1911). While this method increased productivity in manufacturing, it had limitations, as it neglected employee motivation beyond financial rewards—a critical factor in service-driven industries like tourism.
Indeed, during this period, the travel and tourism industry began to expand with the rise of rail and steamship travel, requiring more structured workforce management. However, applying Taylor’s rigid principles to tourism was challenging, as service delivery relied heavily on interpersonal skills rather than repetitive tasks. Scientific Management, therefore, had a limited but notable impact, shaping early ideas of efficiency in operational roles within hotels and transport services.
The Human Relations Movement (1930s–1950s)
A pivotal development in HRM occurred with the Human Relations Movement, spurred by Elton Mayo’s Hawthorne Studies (conducted between 1927 and 1932). These experiments, carried out at the Western Electric Hawthorne Works in the USA, revealed that employee productivity was influenced not just by pay but by social factors, such as group dynamics and managerial attention (Mayo, 1933). This marked a shift towards recognising the psychological and emotional needs of workers, contrasting sharply with Taylor’s mechanical view.
For the travel and tourism industry, this era was transformative. As mass tourism grew, driven by increased leisure time and disposable income in the post-war years, companies began to prioritise customer-facing staff training. The human relations approach encouraged better communication and motivation strategies, which were vital for delivering quality service—still a cornerstone of tourism today. However, while this movement introduced a more humane perspective, it was criticised for being overly paternalistic, often lacking depth in addressing systemic workplace issues (Armstrong, 2009).
The Formalisation of HRM (1960s–1980s)
By the mid-20th century, HRM began to emerge as a distinct discipline, moving beyond personnel administration to a strategic function. In the 1960s and 1970s, HRM focused on aligning employee goals with organisational objectives through policies on recruitment, training, and industrial relations. The concept of ‘human capital’ gained traction, recognising employees as valuable assets rather than mere labour (Boxall and Purcell, 2011). Legislation, such as the UK’s Equal Pay Act 1970 and Race Relations Act 1976, further shaped HRM by enforcing fair treatment and diversity in the workplace.
In travel and tourism, the formalisation of HRM was evident as airlines, hotels, and tour operators expanded globally, necessitating sophisticated workforce planning. For instance, training programmes became essential to maintain service standards across international markets. However, challenges persisted, particularly in balancing cost control with employee satisfaction, a tension that remains relevant today. Arguably, this period solidified HRM’s role as a mediator between organisational needs and employee rights, though its application in tourism often prioritised operational efficiency over strategic innovation.
Contemporary HRM: Globalisation and Technology (1990s–Present)
The late 20th and early 21st centuries have seen HRM evolve dramatically, driven by globalisation, technological advancements, and changing workforce expectations. Strategic HRM now focuses on talent management, diversity, and employee engagement, reflecting a holistic view of organisational success (Armstrong, 2009). Technology, particularly HR information systems and online recruitment platforms, has revolutionised how firms in all sectors, including tourism, manage their staff. Furthermore, the rise of remote working and gig economy roles, accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, has introduced new challenges in maintaining employee cohesion.
In the travel and tourism industry, globalisation has necessitated cross-cultural training to cater to diverse clientele, while technology enables personalised customer service through data-driven insights. However, issues such as high staff turnover and seasonal employment persist, requiring innovative HRM solutions. Generally, contemporary HRM in tourism must balance technological integration with the human touch that defines the sector’s appeal, a complex but critical task.
Conclusion
The historical development of HRM from the 1800s to the present reveals a gradual shift from labour control to strategic, people-centric management. Beginning with basic personnel practices during the Industrial Revolution, HRM evolved through Scientific Management, the Human Relations Movement, and formalisation in the mid-20th century, to its current focus on technology and globalisation. For the travel and tourism industry, this evolution underscores the importance of employee engagement and adaptability in delivering exceptional service, even as challenges like high turnover and technological integration remain. Understanding this progression equips students and practitioners with the insight to address modern workforce issues in tourism, ensuring that HRM continues to support both organisational goals and employee well-being. The implications of this history suggest that while HRM has progressed significantly, its application in service industries must remain flexible to meet ever-changing global and technological demands.
References
- Armstrong, M. (2009) Armstrong’s Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice. 11th edn. Kogan Page.
- Boxall, P. and Purcell, J. (2011) Strategy and Human Resource Management. 3rd edn. Palgrave Macmillan.
- Cole, G.A. (2002) Personnel and Human Resource Management. 5th edn. Continuum.
- Mayo, E. (1933) The Human Problems of an Industrial Civilization. Macmillan.
- Taylor, F.W. (1911) The Principles of Scientific Management. Harper & Brothers.
(Word count: 1052, including references)
